Helping you make sense of schooling today
June 2002 • Vol. 4 • Issue 4

Managing Editor
Caralee Adams

Contributing Editor
Neal McCluskey

Jeanne Allen
President

1001 Connecticut Ave., NW
Suite 204
Washington, DC 20036
202-822-9000
800-521-2118
Fax: 202-822-5077
parentpower@edreform.com

http://www.edreform.com/

Reading IS Rocket Science: What You Need to Know about Reading Instruction

A child’s love of language starts in the home. Playing rhyming games, talking at the dinner table, and reading together are all critical ways in which parents nurture reading skills. Once your child enters school, your role doesn’t end – it merely changes. To make sure children become strong readers, parents need to coach, monitor and advocate for quality reading instruction.

As much as 20 percent of school age children have difficulty learning to read. However, if the right kind of good, intensive, explicit instruction and intervention are provided, that number can be reduced to as little as 5 percent.

There is now scientific evidence about the best ways to teach reading, based on extensive research from the National Reading Panel. After reviewing thousands of research studies on reading, holding public hearings, and consulting with leading educational organizations, this panel came out with recommendations that emphasize the importance of teaching phonics skills and phonemic awareness, as well as fluency and reading comprehension. While the research was released more than two years ago, many parents aren’t aware of the finding and schools haven’t adopted these proven methods.

“Change is generally a slow process and changing curriculum means buying new materials and many schools are strapped,” says Peggy McCardle Associate Chief, Child Development and Behavior Branch, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. It can also be threatening. “We need to convince teachers that change is a good and important thing.”

Once given the curriculum, teacher must know how to best teach it. Therefore, training needs to be reformed to reflect these best practices in reading instruction.

To advocate for sound reading instruction, parents can work with the school and parent-teacher organizations to inform them about the new research on reading (see resource box for web sites with parent and teacher guides) and support professional development for teachers.

Make sure your school is doing all it can to track your child’s reading development. The longer a reading problem goes undetected, the more difficult it is to correct.

“It’s critical that parents follow their child’s progress and know objective reading benchmarks for kids,” says Susan Hall, co-author of Parenting a Struggling Reader.
That’s why Hall and others are pushing schools to use early literacy screen tools. Quick assessments (less than 15 minutes), which can be given by a teacher or reading specialist, should take place three times a year starting in kindergarten through grade three, says Hall. Benchmarks for reading accomplishments have been published by the National Academy of Sciences in a report about preventing reading difficulties in young children.

Early literacy screening tools (an example of which can be found at www.getreadytoread.org) don’t meet resistance when introduced to teachers, but they are somewhat new and the word is still getting out.

“It’s a very powerful predictor if a kid is going to read well later,” says Hall. “There is no reason why every teacher in the U.S. shouldn’t be using this tool.” The No Child Left Behind Act, the new federal education law, includes language supporting the early literacy screening tool.

Ongoing monitoring and assessment should be a part of every good reading program. If you ask a teacher if they monitor and keep records of a child’s reading progress, they will likely say yes. The better question, says McCardle, is: “Do you have the tools you need to really monitor kids? Are you doing periodic assessments of each child, and how often do you reassess and think about reorganizing which reading group they are in?”

While we want kids reading by age nine, the vigilance shouldn’t end there. “The job is not done by the fourth grade,” says McCardle. “We want to keep teaching reading through middle school and high school.” Later on, the emphasis is on building comprehension skills.

Parents need to work with schools to get best practices put into place. Sometimes parents are reluctant to confront the school about issues of curriculum and assessment. “Even though we as parents feel that we are crossing over the line, when it comes to reading that early time counts. You don’t have a choice, you have to stay involved.” says Hall.

What should be happening at school – and at home with reading

To ensure your child is getting the best reading instruction in school, parents need to know – and be able to articulate – what constitutes a quality reading program. Here are some highlights from a parent guide based on the research of the National Reading Panel.

If your child is just beginning to learn to read at school, you should see teachers:

•Teaching the sounds of language.
•Teaching the letters of the alphabet
•Helping children learn and use new words.
•Reading with children every day using expression.
•At home you can help by reading books with rhymes and playing word games.
•Help children separate sounds of words and point out letters wherever you see them.
•If your child is just beginning to read, at school you should see teachers:
•Teaching phonics (how sounds and letters are related).
•Having children practice letter-sound relationships.
•Helping children write letter-sound relationships they know by using them in words and sentences.
•Asking children questions to show them how to think about the meaning of what they are reading
•At home you can help by pointing out letter-sound relationships on labels, newspapers and signs, and listening to your child read and encouraging them.
•If your child is reading, at school you should see teachers:
•Continuing to teach letter-sound relationships for children who need more practice.
•Teaching the meaning of words.
•Teaching students to use dictionaries and how to get clues about a word from the rest of the sentence.
•Helping children understand what they are reading.

At home you can help by rereading familiar books to build confidence, increase accuracy by correcting your child as he reads aloud, and discuss and ask questions about stories (i.e.: Who are the main characters? What did you learn?) to improve comprehension.

Ten tips to help your child learn to love reading.

Laura Backes, author of Best Books for Kids Who Think They Hate to Read (2001 Random House), offers some strategies to help get your children excited about reading.

1. Play it cool. Don’t nag or beg your child to spend time reading. Instead, show how reading is an enjoyable part of everyday life. Share information as you read the newspaper. Rope your child into reading during routine activities.

2. Know your child. No matter how broad or obscure, your child’s passions can be found in a book or magazine. Does your son fancy Buzz Lightyear from the Toy Story movie? Get the book. While you’re at it, pick out a few other books about astronauts and space travel.

3. Let your child lead. Try to allow your child as much freedom as possible. Don’t judge your child’s personal interests. It gives children a sense of power when they pursue a subject and become experts on a topic.

4. Don’t give up lap time. Keep read-aloud time in your routine even once kids can read independently. Many children in fourth and fifth grade still love being read to. This helps them associate reading with pleasant, shared family time.

5. Discuss books with your child. This may smack of testing or homework, so use this tip with caution. However, children love giving their opinions on books. Ask your child about parts of the story he did or didn’t like. Discussing books you’ve read together show your child that you respect his interests and opinions.

6. Don’t push your child to “read up.” Don’t pass up fun books for kids. Reading in itself in an educational activity. If your child finds books interesting instead of overwhelming, she’ll want more.

7. Expose your child to a broad range of experiences. The more life experiences a child has - from going to a museum to baking cookies – the more likely he’ll discover passions and interests that connect with books.

8. Connect reading with other activities. Reading books can be a springboard for activities. Read a book about ladybugs and then take a magnifying glass out to the backyard and find some live specimens.

9. Promote your child’s oral language. Kids need to develop their spoken language skills to be good readers. Talk your kids and ask lots of open-ended questions.

10. Give your child time to read. It’s easy to turn a well-rounded child into an overbooked one. It’s during those quiet, unscheduled hours that kids have the chance to think, daydream and read.

Back to Top

Small classes or small schools? Which is better?

Parents with children in small schools are significantly happier with their children's education than are parents with kids in large schools, according to a recent Public Agenda report.

But while evidence favors small schools, small school parents normally associate success not with school size, but class size.

Talk to parents at virtually any school where classes are larger than 20, and you’ll most likely hear a constant refrain of “if only we had smaller classes.” Indeed, parents and school officials often link a teacher’s success to how large or small a class is. But the evidence just doesn’t hold.

Intuitively, class-size reduction makes sense; fewer students per teacher should mean more attention per child. It’s certainly true that smaller classes can have benefits for teachers in terms of workload. It’s also the case that a large class with one or more disruptive students may impede a teacher’s ability to serve all children. The research about what makes an effective course of instruction, however, rarely points to class size.

Then why the public demand for smaller classes? Because an experiment with class size in a Tennessee produced good results for children, especially minorities. California tried a new initiative to reduce its average class size from 28 to 20 students. But the effort in that state actually failed to yield results in achievement, leading many to question the $8 billion that was spent. Few policymakers there, however, will actually concede that.

Researchers at Harvard University and the University of Rochester have also confirmed that simply reducing classes does not guarantee improved achievement. A look at international comparisons is also telling.

In the recent Third International Math and Science Study (TIMSS), Eighth grade students in Singapore, Korea, Chinese Taipei, Japan and Hong Kong had the highest scores. They also have large classes, with 10 to 20 more students than the U.S. average. On a national level, between 1960 and 1995 the pupil-teacher ratio fell by roughly one-third. In that same time SAT scores declined and performance on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) has been stagnant.

So what’s a parent to do?

There is a strategy that offers hope, and it does involve reduction – not classes, but school-size reduction. “The research is pretty clear on this point: Smaller schools help promote learning," says Andrew Rotherham of the Progressive Policy Institute. The University of Minnesota's Center for School Change found that "small schools are safer and, in general, students in small schools learn more." Similarly, smaller schools produce a greater feeling of student "connectedness," leading to reduced risks of violence, substance abuse, suicide and pregnancy, as reported by Dr. Robert Blum in the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health.

So why is class-size-reduction the reform of choice, even for parents whose children are thriving in small schools? It is mainly a function of politics. Teachers unions like class-size reduction because it requires that more teachers be hired, expanding union rolls. It also promises to lighten workloads -- fewer students per teacher means fewer papers to grade and students to track. Politicians, in many cases, want the support of unions and have found that this issue polls well so they have become proponents of class-size reduction.

The key to replacing the class-size myth with small school reality, it appears, does not lie with policy makers. It lies with parents, who must persuade politicians to support small schools and abandon politically expedient but, educationally worthless, class-size-reduction programs. After all, politicians respond to whoever has the votes, and parents represent a very large voting block. Overcoming the effect of years of class size myth perpetuation will require significant effort. Once parents fully embrace the need for smaller schools, however, policy makers will follow.

Resource Box:

www.nationalreadingpanel.org
Here, you will find much of the findings of the National Reading Panel in their entirety or in easy-to-read documents. The parent guide is called “Put Reading First, Helping Your Child Learn to Read” and is geared for preschool through grade three. The teacher guide is called, “Put Reading First: The Research Building Blocks for Teaching Children to Read.” Or call 1-800-228-8813.

www.nifl.gov
National Institute for Literacy administers The Partnership for Reading and other programs that support the development of high quality state, regional, and national literacy services.

www.nifl.gov/partnershipforreading/publications/recommended.html
Access to a variety of publications on reading

www.nifl.gov/partnershipforreading/questions/questions_about.html
Here you can post questions about scientifically based reading instruction.

www.nichd.nih.gov
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development
One of the three partners in The Partnership for Reading, the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD) conducts research and administers a variety of programs.

http://dibels.uoregon.edu/index.php
The Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills (DIBELS) are a set of standardized, individually administered measures of early literacy development. They are designed to be short (one minute) fluency measures used to regularly monitor the development of pre-reading and early reading skills. At this site you can download the assessments free.

www.publicagenda.org
Public Agenda provides the report “Sizing Things Up: What Parents, Teachers, and Students Think About Large and Small High Schools.”

Back to Top


Helping You Make Sense of Schooling Today