Sign up for our newsletter

Newswire: March 5, 2013

Vol. 15, No. 9

OK PINOCCHIO. Last week, Newswire sparked a mini-debate on what the sequester really means for education. But as CER president Jeanne Allen points out in today’s National Journal, “… that among all of these thousands of entities that spend and receive federal money, no one seems to know or to be even talking about how the almighty federal dollar flows.” The reality that CER continues to point out, is that most of the money has already been collected by states and districts. Thankfully we’re not alone in holding the Administration accountable for irresponsible rhetoric about a frenzy of “pink slips.” In fact, the US Department of Education has yet to produce any district-level evidence of lay-offs, according to the Wall Street Journal.

COVER UP. The Worcester County Teachers Association in Maryland has been making headlines as news broke of their botched attempt to cover-up the fact that Denise Inez Owens, the union’s former treasurer embezzled over $430,000 of teacher dues to fund her gambling addiction. In 2009 when the MSEA (state affiliate of the NEA) learned of the crime, they merely forced Owens to resign. We know these union contracts are ironclad, but come on, they sent a known-criminal back to teaching in a middle school classroom! Finally justice has been served, but where’s the accountability and “common good” that the union leadership supposedly values?

EXPANDING CHOICE. In a press conference last week Alabama Governor Robert Bentley applauded the legislature for sending an individual and corporate tax credit bill to his desk, “I truly believe this is historic education reform and it will benefit students and families across Alabama regardless of their income and regardless of where they live. I’m so proud we have done this for the children of this state and especially the children who are in failing school systems and had no way out. Now, they have a way out.” We couldn’t agree more Governor Bentley; now get back to the drawing board to finally bring charters to your state. There must be something in the water because in his 2013 Budget Address last week, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie proposed a $2 million pilot opportunity scholarship program for low-income students in failing schools. A small plan, but at least it’s a start.

ON CHARTERS. Charter schools will be all the buzz in Tennessee and Mississippi state houses today. The Volunteer state’s House Education Committee will take up HB 702, a very modest proposal that would allow the state board of education to authorize charter schools on an appeal. Currently only local school boards and the Achievement School District can authorize charter schools. Charter school leaders and parents are rallying in Nashville in support of the proposal.

Today, Mississippi lawmakers are poised to act on legislation expanding charter schools in the state, trying to resolve differences between the House and Senate versions of bills. Some issues include: whether school boards in districts with “C’’ ratings will be able to veto charter schools, whether students will be able to cross district lines to attend charter schools elsewhere, whether schools will be able to join the state pension system, and whether for-profit companies will be allowed to run charter schools.

VIRTUAL VINDICATION. Yesterday, the lead plaintiff in a class action securities lawsuit against K12 Inc. voluntarily and permanently dismissed their claims made about K12-managed schools, helping to drown out the often-unsubstantiated charges similarly made by critics and echoed repeatedly by the media. With a bit of luck, the dismissal of these claims will help put to rest these charges and serve as a sort of virtual vindication.

Daily Headlines for March 5, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

Duncan Says He Misspoke When Describing Pink Slips for Teachers
Wall Street Journal, March 5, 2013

Education Secretary Arne Duncan said Monday he chose the wrong words last week when he said teachers were already receiving “pink slips”—layoff notices—due to the spending cuts mandated by the sequester.

On School Choice
Huffington Post, March 4, 2013

Something remarkable is occurring in the arena of schools: shopping. Not late summer back-to-school specials or runs on novelty lunch-boxes, but shopping for schools themselves.

FROM THE STATES

ALABAMA

Voucher Bill Irks Educators
News Courier, AL, March 5, 2013

School leaders across the state are still fuming over a bill passed last week that will provide tax credits to parents who want to move their children from a failing public school to a private school.

Blow to Public Schools
Times Daily, AL, March 5, 2013

Republicans in the state Legislature embarrassed themselves Thursday with the covert passage of a law that funnels tax dollars from public schools to private ones.

CALIFORNIA

Late Donations Bolster Pro-Deasy School Board Candidates
Los Angeles Times Blog, CA, March 5, 2013

Two eleventh hour donations have added financial muscle to a campaign seeking to bolster Los Angeles schools Supt. John Deasy through the results of Tuesday’s Board of Education elections.

Potential Layoffs Tied To Temecula Valley Charter Changes
San Diego Union Tribune, CA, March 4, 2013

“It’s becoming too costly for the charter school to follow the district’s pay scale,” she said, adding that the Temecula Preparatory Charter School operates under a similar arrangement.

County Superintendent Frustrated By Snub Related To Charter Report
Contra Costa Times, CA, March 4, 2013

The latest flare-up occurred after the district superintendent and a couple of school board members secretly commissioned a financial analysis of the costs to the district from Clayton Valley High School’s conversion to a charter school.

California School Districts Are In Better Financial Shape, Officials Say
Los Angeles Times, CA, March 5, 2013

A state report shows that the number of districts at risk of not meeting financial obligations dropped to 124 from 188 last May. But 2 L.A. County districts joined the list of at-risk districts.

Students Learning Lessons In Social Responsibility
Los Angeles Times, CA, March 5, 2013

World-renowned inventors, explorers and artists encourage student teams participating in the Aspen Challenge to develop solutions to social problems.

Parents Allege Massive Enrollment Fraud at Carpenter Community Charter in Studio City
Los Angeles Daily News, CA, March 4, 2013

Los Angeles Unified will let schools use public records to verify student addresses after a high-performing charter in Studio City complained that scores of parents from outside the neighborhood committed fraud to get their kids admitted, officials said Monday.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Another Reason Charters Are Taking Over D.C.
Washington Examiner, DC, March 4, 2013

On Monday, The Washington Examiner’s Rachel Baye reported that the D.C. Public School system is negotiating with the Washington Teachers’ Union to implement longer school days and a longer school year.

FLORIDA

Another Failed Orlando Charter ‘A Disaster’ For Students, Teachers
Orlando Sentinel, FL, March 4, 2013

It was clear to teachers at the Einstein Montessori School in Orlando that something was very wrong when school opened for business last fall.

Bills Would Let Funds Follow Students
Tallahassee Democrat, FL, March 5, 2013

Legislation filed by committee chairmen in both the House and Senate would allow students to use state education funds to pay for private schools or other education options.

GEORGIA

Federal Judge Rules Against DeKalb School Board
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, March 4, 2013

A federal judge refused to prevent the replacement of six DeKalb County school board members who lost their seats over a threatened loss of accreditation, and now Gov. Nathan Deal must find appointees to mend the torn district.

INDIANA

More Need Flexibility Of Vouchers
Journal Gazette, IN, March 5, 2013

Indiana’s school voucher program is thriving, and lawmakers are looking for practical ways to increase access so that more families can benefit from high-quality education options. This is good news for Hoosiers – and here’s why.

IOWA

Iowa Senate Bill Would Raise Starting Teacher Pay To $35K
Sioux City Journal, IA, March 4, 2013

Starting teachers would earn $35,000 a year and districts would be required to adopt new professional career ladders under an education reform bill filed Monday.

KANSAS

Legislation Promotes Kansas Charter Schools
Kansas City Star, KS, March 4, 2013

Two bills in the Legislature would give charter schools greater freedom to open and operate in Kansas, where such schools have struggled to find a foothold.

LOUISIANA

Ruling Could Work Against Vouchers
Daily Advertiser, LA, March 5, 2013

Monday’s ruling striking down Jindal administration changes in teacher tenure may be used to attack the voucher system, which is already on its way to the state Supreme Court.

Judge Throws Out Tenure Law
The Advocate, LA, March 5, 2013

One of Gov. Bobby Jindal’s signature laws that makes it harder for teachers to earn and retain a form of job protection, called tenure, was declared unconstitutional Monday.

Algiers Charter Group Promotes Interim CEO To Permanent Status
Times-Picayune, LA, March 4, 2013

The Algiers Charter School Association board voted on Feb. 28 to hire Adrian Morgan as CEO, giving him a one-year contract. Morgan had served as interim CEO since August 2012.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

Lift The Cap: Free The Charter Schools
Union Leader, NH, March 5, 2013

The House will have the opportunity this Wednesday to fix a recent mistake that has hindered the expansion of needed public schools. Legislators should pass it with no hesitations.

Voucher Program Takes Cash From Public Schools
Portsmouth Herald, NH, March 5, 2013

The more I learn about New Hampshire’s school voucher program, the more I realize it is a solution in search of a problem.

NEW JERSEY

State Board of Education to Release Regulations for Teacher Evaluations Tomorrow
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, March 5, 2013

Some wiggle room built in to give system room to evolve, but will it be enough to head off arguments over student test scores?

NEW MEXICO

Bill’s Merit Pay Idea Isn’t Best Solution
Albuquerque Journal, NM, March 4, 2013

Hidden within HB2, the budget bill now under consideration in our state Senate throws $3 million into a merit pay program based on proven failed policies.

NEW YORK

Just Another Hijacked Parents’ Group
New York Post, NY, March 5, 2013

Mind you, CPAC is supposed to be the voice of parents inside the city Education Department. But, like everything education-related, the teachers union successfully got its hooks into the group.

NORTH CAROLINA

New STEM Charter School Proposed in Winston-Salem
Winston-Salem Journal, NC, March 4, 2013

A proposal for a new K-5 charter school in Winston-Salem focused on science, technology, engineering and math is among 70 applications for new charters received by the N.C. Department of Public Instruction.

State Gets Record Number of Charter Applications for 2014
Durham Herald Sun, NC, March 4, 2013

Seven new public charter schools could be on the way to our region. The state Department of Public Education’s Office of Charter Schools Monday announced it had received 70 applications for charter programs that would, if approved, open in August 2014 throughout North Carolina.

29 Seek To Open Charter Schools In Charlotte Area
Charlotte Observer, NC, March 4, 2013

Charlotte’s charter boom is poised to keep growing, with 19 applications to open new schools in Mecklenburg County in 2014 and another 10 from surrounding counties.

NORTH DAKOTA

Baesler Withdraws State’s Application For Waiver
Minot Daily News, ND, March 5, 2013

“The idea of developing a state-determined plan was very inviting,” said Baesler in a press release. “The further we progressed through the waiver process the more we felt we were being asked to adopt another national, one-size-fits-all model. We discovered there is very little flexibility for us in the ESEA Waiver. Schools and teachers would actually see very little relief.”

OHIO

State Should Give Cleveland School Reform Plan A Chance To Work
Cleveland Plain Dealer, OH, March 4, 2013

The Cleveland and Lorain school districts have fallen into the academic doghouse, failing to meet federal standards for four years and earning the state’s lowest academic rating — “emergency,” essentially an F. Under state law, that triggers the creation of academic distress commissions for each district with the right to run both systems.

The Future Of Ohio Schools
Youngstown Vindicator, OH, March 4, 2013

But it is already clear that charter schools — or community schools as they’re called in Columbus — and parochial schools are potentially huge winners. This is both perplexing in the case of charter schools and troublesome in the case of parochial schools.

PENNSYLVANIA

Senators Want Scrutiny Of Charter Schools In Pa.
Times Leader, PA, March 4, 2013

Some lawmakers on Monday called for stronger state regulation of Pennsylvania’s charter and cyber-charter schools, while others derided Gov. Tom Corbett’s plan to finance new school grants by privatizing liquor and wine sales as a political gimmick.

Proposed Pay Cuts Enrage PFT Members
Philadelphia Daily News, PA, March 5, 2013

The Philadelphia Federation of Teachers is looking at a grim future if school-district officials get their way in current negotiations.

Philipsburg-Osceola Area Board Members Reject Charter School Application
Centre Daily Times, PA, March 5, 2013

An application for a charter school in the Philipsburg-Osceola area has been officially rejected by the school board.

RHODE ISLAND

Achievement First Selects 176 Students From 1,150 Applicants
Valley Breeze, RI, March 4, 2013

Achievement First, a network of nonprofit public charter schools, held a blind lottery for its initial class of 176 kindergarten and 1st-grade students at Achievement First Providence Mayoral Academy last Friday. The results were verified by independent auditor Andsager, Bartlett & Pieroni, and a separate witness from the Rhode Island Department of Education.

TENNESSEE

KIPP Is Working
Memphis Commercial Appeal, TN, March 5, 2013

The results are in. And they are impressive. A new independent study of the KIPP schools operating in 20 cities and states, including Memphis, shows without a doubt that the KIPP method of educating at-risk kids works.

School Board Has Sticker Shock Over Increased Charter School Costs
Nashville City Paper, TN, March 4, 2013

A routine meeting to review Metro Nashville Public Schools’ nearly $765 million budget proposal for next school year Monday afternoon broke into a makeshift policy meeting about the financial effect of opening more charter schools.

House to Consider Broadening State Charter Authorizer
Nashville Public Radio, TN, March 4, 2013

The state House will consider creating an entirely new panel for authorizing charter schools at the state level. It’s part of a compromise set to be heard in an education committee Tuesday.

Fight Over School Voucher Bill Escalates In Tenn. Legislature
Memphis Commercial Appeal, TN, March 4, 2013

The legislative battle over school vouchers in Tennessee is escalating, with the bill set for committee votes in the House on Tuesday and the Senate on Wednesday, and the state Democratic Party chairman attacking it Monday.

New Democratic Chairman Roy Herron Criticizes Voucher Campaign By Outside Groups
The Tennessean, TN, March 5, 2013

The new leader of the Tennessee Democratic Party attacked “out-of-state guns” for trying to sway the state legislature on education issues through hefty political contributions and television advertising.

Schools Boost Budget Request
The Tennessean, TN, March 4, 2013

Metro Nashville school officials are looking to increase the district’s budget by $44 million for next year — a sizable bump they say is largely to replace money drained by new charter schools.

Charter School Compromise Under Consideration in Tennessee
WKYU, TN, March 5, 2013

The Tennessee House will consider creating an entirely new panel for authorizing charter schools at the state level. It’s part of a compromise set to be heard in an education committee Tuesday.

TEXAS

Senate Panel To Look At Proposal For Special Education Vouchers
Austin American-Statesman, TX, March 4, 2013

Underlying the expansive “school choice” debate roiling the Texas Capitol is the contention that a traditional neighborhood public school might not be right for every child.

VIRGINIA

Gov. Bob McDonnell to Lead School Choice Scholarship Foundation in Virginia
Washington Examiner, DC, March 4, 2013

Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell is helping organize a nonprofit foundation to provide voucherlike scholarships to Virginia students who want to attend private schools, capitalizing on a new law he championed last year.

Patrick Henry Charter School Gets Another 5 Years To Prove Itself
WWBT, VA, March 4, 2013

Parents, children and teachers at the Patrick Henry School of Science and Arts are breathing a collective sigh of relief. The Commonwealth’s first charter elementary school has been granted another five years to prove itself.

WASHINGTON

WEA Targets Initiative 1240
The Columbian, WA, March 4, 2013

As expected, the teachers union has filed a legal challenge to Washington’s new charter school law, Initiative 1240, which was approved by voters last fall.

WEST VIRGINIA

Grade: Incomplete: Tomblin’s Education Proposal Lacking Key Parts
Martinsburg Journal, WV, March 5, 2013

West Virginians need all the help we can get to improve our public school system. A massive education reform bill introduced last week in the Legislature includes at least one failure to seek help from a source ready, willing and very able to provide it.

Too Much Emphasis Put On Seniority In Teacher Hiring
The Herald-Dispatch, WV, March 5, 2013

One of the critical elements of Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin’s education reform package is giving local school officials more flexibility.

WISCONSIN

District Considers New Design Charter For High Schoolers
La Crosse Tribune, WI, March 5, 2013

A design-focused charter school in the La Crosse School District could expand to include high school students.

Gov. Walker’s Voucher System Problematic
Wisconsin State Journal, WI, March 5, 2013

Gov. Scott Walker recently announced plans to expand the school voucher program in Wisconsin, providing more students from underperforming school districts the option to attend private schools. He said doing so would allow all students in the state access to a quality education, “regardless of their zip code.”

WYOMING

Opinions Vary On Wyoming No Child Left Behind Waiver Application
Casper Star-Tribune, WY, March 5, , 2013

Wyoming Department of Education officials say feedback about an application to waive federal education requirements has been positive. However, Superintended of Public Instruction Cindy Hill opposes the waiver and says she’s not the only one with concerns.

ONLINE LEARNING

Schools Offer More Online
Port Huron Times Herald, MI, March 5, 2013

The 21st century classroom is evolving, and school districts are trying to keep up.

Bridges Virtual Academy In Merrill Continues To Attract Attention
Wausau Daily Herald, WI, March 5, 2013

Families are clamoring to get into the Merrill Area Public Schools charter school, which delivers public education resources to home-schooling families.

Virtual Public Charter School Opens Enrollment For The 2013-2014 School Year
KATC, LA, March 4, 2013

Louisiana Connections Academy. a fully accredited provider of high-quality, highly accountable virtual K-12 schooling, opens enrollment for the 2013-2014 school year today, March 4, and enrollment sessions with parents and students will begin across the state on March 5.

Grapevine-Colleyville’s ‘virtual Academy’ Won’t Be Easy
Fort Worth Star Telegram, TX, March 4, 2013

The Grapevine-Colleyville school district’s decision to offer a full-time, open-enrollment virtual academy puts it at the forefront of the merger between education and technology, offering students across Texas the chance of significant learning advantages.

USD 308 Considers Virtual School Option
Hutchinson News, KS, March 5, 2013

Hutchinson USD 308 could launch a virtual school, an online alternative for students in elementary school through high school, in 2014-2015.

Leadership Goes Beyond Pinocchio’s Noses

by Jeanne Allen
Response to “Arne Duncan’s Distracting Gaffe“, National Journal
March 5, 2013

Irresponsible Leadership That Goes Beyond Pinocchio’s Noses

The Center for Education Reform wrote last week about the Chicken Little behavior this administration is leading on education, along with countless school leaders and association spokespeople. We are happy to have sparked a mini-debate on the subject! But what remains absolutely astonishing is that among all of these thousands of entities that spend and receive federal money, no one seems to know or to be even talking about how the almighty federal dollar flows.

NEWS FLASH — there isn’t a pool of money sitting in the Department of the Treasury with educational purpose just waiting to be cut. The reality is MOST OF THE MONEY FOR THIS YEAR – almost 90% of it — has been drawn down or collected by states and districts!!! Some states — like New Jersey — already have all of their money for the year.

Of that which remains — limited Title funds, some Head Start, for example — between 5-8% of the remaining 10% will likely be reduced. That amounts to less a half a percent overall for the year!

I’ve personally called people who should know whether and how federal spending flows and what might be left that states need, yet they’ve been clueless. There is no public information available by the US Department of Education that shows what has been distributed to every state and district and what remains. Without data, no wonder school districts are in a tizzy!

It’s easy to incite outrage when our leaders — who the public presumes understand policy and budgets — tell people they are going to lose their beloved teachers, the arts, after-school, food, early childhood and more.

The reality is that while school and school district bean counters most likely know for certain what money they have, what funds they might lose and how, the US Education Secretary clearly doesn’t, and superintendents and school board officials aren’t saying. After all, it’s easier to create a problem than a solution.

That’s plausible, some might say, but what about the fiscal year that starts October 1?

Well, Congress must contend with pending budget issues regardless of sequestration, and yes the uncertainly of spending levels absolutely affects the plans some may have had. Schools and districts should prepare for the kind of reduction that is often caused by natural enrollment fluctuations when student populations change, either due to birth rate impact, changes in regional composition, or even competition.

Financial fluctuations are a fact of life for most public enterprises. It’s not new and it happens every few years for schools, regardless of who’s in power. In the all-important enterprise of education, it’s time we recognize that what we know and how we conduct ourselves is especially critical to the children and students whose lives we aspire to improve. We must demonstrate that truth, problem-solving, intellectual rigor and the ability to weather any storm are critical attributes worth having and worth learning, in and out of school.

Daily Headlines for March 4, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

NATIONAL COVERAGE

An Unfortunate Class Distinction In Schools
Washington Post, DC, March 3, 2013

Regarding the Feb. 25 Metro story “D.C. school choice creates a niche”: As a retired public school educator and a parent, I was particularly troubled by two quotes.

Study Says KIPP Student Gains Substantial
Washington Post, DC, March 3, 2013

KIPP, formerly known as the Knowledge Is Power Program, has had more success than any other large educational organization in raising the achievement of low-income students, both nationally and in the District. But many good educators, burned by hopeful stories in the past, have wondered whether KIPP was for real.

Standardized Testing Becomes The Great Divide In Schools Policy
Los Angeles Times, CA, March 3, 2013

Use of standardized tests in schools is growing, but so is push-back – an issue playing out in L.A. school board elections.

Should ‘Common’ Be Education’s Goal?
Detroit News, MI, March 4, 2013

That’s a fine aim, and it began as a states-led effort. Many states, including Michigan, approved the standards early on. Yet shortly thereafter, the U.S. Department of Education embraced the initiative and soon began pushing states to adopt the Common Core as a condition for being granted a waiver from No Child Left Behind requirements.

FROM THE STATES

ALABAMA

Educators Question New Tax-Credit Bill
Tuscaloosa News, AL, March 3, 2013

Local education officials are upset and wondering about the future of their school systems following the Alabama Legislature’s sudden passage of a bill Thursday giving tax credits to parents who move their children from failing public schools to private schools.

ALASKA

Senate Education Panel Takes Up Voucher Issue
Juneau Empire, AK, March 3, 2013

A Senate panel began hearings Friday on the subject of school vouchers, less than two weeks after the committee’s chair adamantly declared on the Senate floor that the issue needs to be thoroughly vetted.

CALIFORNIA

National Attention and Cash in Los Angeles School Vote
New York Times, NY, March 4, 2013

On Tuesday, voters in Los Angeles will go to the polls for a mayoral primary. But much of the attention will also be on the three races for the school board, a battle that involves the mayor, the teachers’ union and a host of advocates from across the country — including New York City’s billionaire mayor — who have poured millions of dollars into the races.

COLORADO

Appeals Court Upholds Freedom Of Choice For Accredited Private Or Religious Schools
Colorado Springs Gazette, CO, March 4, 2013

Institutional discrimination against poor and religious families in Douglas County has ended, at least for now.

FLORIDA

Parents Have High Hopes For Spot In Viera Charter
Florida Today, FL, March 2, 2013

Today, Latonik will be among 1,200 student applicants – and their parents – who will learn whether efforts to enroll in a new 650-student charter school in Viera will be rewarded with a slot at the school.

Florida Lawmakers File Bills That Focus On Teacher Pay, Parent Triggers, More
News-Press, FL, March 4, 2013

It’s going to be another wild ride for education: New bills in Tallahassee could shake up parents, teachers and students.

ILLINOIS

CPS Applies Charter Heat
Chicago Tribune, IL, March 4, 2013

In recent days, Chicago Public Schools CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett has thrown some muscle behind her pledge to hold charter schools accountable for academic performance.

INDIANA

Beware Schools’ Charter Shopping
Journal Gazette, IN, March 3, 2013

In 2011, the Indiana legislature passed important legislation to expand the number of quality charter schools and to hold charter schools more accountable for their performance. Unfortunately, that legislation also created a loophole that allows failing charter schools to avoid that stronger accountability, a loophole that some of those schools are now trying to use.

Scholarships Add Layer To Voucher Debate
Journal Gazette, IN, March 3, 2013

Controversial school reform in Indiana that produced publicly funded vouchers for private school students also includes a lesser-known private school scholarship program, which critics say is another way that public funds end up supporting private schools.

School Voucher Expansion Bill Going Through Statehouse
Shelbyville News, IN, March 4, 2013

A measure that expands the choice scholarships in Indiana has cleared the house and is on its way to the Senate. Indiana House Bill 1003 cleared the house last week by a vote of 57-36, despite the fact that the Indiana Supreme Court has not issued a decision on vouchers. The measure is designed to allow more Indiana families to become more easily qualified for the two-year-old voucher program.

KANSAS

Is It Time For A Charter School Revolution In Kansas?
Topeka Capital Journal, KS, March 3, 2013

Some lawmakers are pushing for a new charter law to potentially bring the national ‘school choice’ movement to Kansas

MARYLAND

School Boards May Have To Heed Parents’ Petitions
Cumberland Times-News, MD, March 3, 2013

National education reform advocates support a Maryland bill that would mandate reform for failing schools whenever a majority of parents petition for intervention, but the state superintendent and the state teachers union oppose the idea.

MASSACHUSETTS

More Affirmation For Charter Schools
Lowell Sun, MA, March 3, 2013

A Stanford University study released this week provides great impetus to the state’s charter-school movement and encouragement to parents who seek options for their children.

Site Location Unknown For New Charter School
Boston Globe, MA, March 2, 2013

The Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education on Tuesday granted a charter to the founders of the Pioneer Charter School of Science, but it may not be located in Saugus as expected.

MISSISSIPPI

Young Talks Charter Schools
WTOK, MS, March 3, 2013

Lawmakers in Jackson continue to debate the issue of charter schools in Mississippi.

MONTANA

Education Claims Were Misleading
Helena Independent Record, MT, March 4, 2013

Joe Balyeat’s article in the Independent Record stated that Montana ranked 51st by the Center for Education Reform in its Parent Power Index. Their website showed the ranking had nothing to do with student results; it had to do with state laws giving choices for allocation of education funds.

NEVADA

Denying An Important School Choice
Las Vegas Review-Journal, NV, March 3, 2013

As written, the bill is a stunning attack on parental choice and judgment. Reducing the compulsory age has consequences beyond kindergarten.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

Private Hurt N.H. Public Schools
Portsmouth Herald, NH, March 2, 2013

The voucher tax credit passed in the last Legislature would take money away from our public schools and send it to private, religious and home schools with no accountability to the public.

House Vote Could Set Stage For New Charter Schools
New Hampshire Union Leader, NH, March 4, 2013

The state House of Representatives is scheduled to vote Wednesday on charter school legislation that could set the stage for an end to a moratorium on new charters imposed in September by the Board of Education.

NEW JERSEY

Gov’s Proposed School Aid Has Officials Expressing Needs
The Trentonian, NJ, March 3, 2013

Gov. Chris Christie last week used his proposed State budget to push harder for more school choice for students in struggling districts. In his $32.9 billion spending plan Christie called for more state aid for school districts and also money for some of his favored programs that would make it easier for students to go to school elsewhere.

NEW YORK

Gifted Class Imbalance
Wall Street Journal, March 4, 2013

As New York City switches to a new test to identify children for its gifted-and-talented program, new data show that the overwhelming majority of these coveted, public-school slots still go to white and Asian students.

Inside the World of Charter Schools
New York Times, NY, March 4, 2013

Re “Better Charter Schools in New York City” (editorial, Feb. 23):
While rightly acknowledging the success of charter schools in New York City, you missed the mark in calling the national charter movement a “disappointment.”

Charter School Gearing Up For Fall Opening
Utica Observer Dispatch, NY, March 3, 2013

The Mohawk Valley’s first charter school has a home. The next step: hiring staff and enrolling students.

NORTH DAKOTA

North Dakota Home Schoolers Fight Testing
Grand Forks Herald, ND, March 4, 2013

North Dakota, one of a handful of states requiring high-stakes testing for home schoolers, has long been known for having tougher requirements compared to the rest of the nation. This bill is one step toward easing its reputation and giving home-school parents more freedom, said Theresa Deckert, spokeswoman for the North Dakota Home School Association.

OHIO

Westerville Schools Losing Kids, Funding To Charters
Columbus Dispatch, OH, March 4, 2013

Students are leaving Westerville schools at a rate that has alarmed district officials, spurring them to seek ways to draw students back and retain others.

Charter School Money Is Big Question Mark In Gov. John Kasich’s Education Budget
Cleveland Plain Dealer, OH, March 3, 2013

Much of the debate so far on Gov. John Kasich’s education budget has focused on whether he would give enough state money to public schools and how he would distribute it between poor and rich districts.

PENNSYLVANIA

School Reform Finds A Home
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, March 3, 2013

Teach for America, on whose board Manekin once sat, will be taking 13,000 square feet for its operations, and many of those renting apartments will be TFA teachers. There will be a coffee shop, outdoor courtyards, and free parking. The nonprofits will be given conference-room space, a lunchroom, and events designed to foster collaboration among groups that share a vision but have different missions.

Question Of The Week Responses: York Charter School Conversion13
York Daily Record, PA, March 3, 2013

I do not support York County’s proposal to make more charter schools. For one thing, taxes will go up. We need more buses and school buildings. What is happening to the buildings that we have?

Charter School Friends, Foes Air Their Feelings
Intelligence Journal, PA, March 3, 2013

Onal quaffed the energy drink prior to a Feb. 19 Lancaster school board hearing on the proposed Academy of Business and Entrepreneurship Charter School. The four-hour hearing got out of hand, with Onal — president of the charter school board — accusing opponents of lying. Other confrontations between charter school backers and foes prompted school officials to call police.

RHODE ISLAND

RI Charter Schools See Huge Increase In Applications
Go Local Prov, RI, March 2, 2013

Rhode Island’s public charter schools have seen a large increase in interest from parents deciding where their children should be educated, so much so that a total of 7,900 applications were sent in for the less than 800 openings available leading up to this year’s so-called “lottery day.”

TENNESSEE

Nashville Schools’ Stakes Are High For New Academics Chief
The Tennessean, TN, March 4, 2013

From his Bransford Avenue office, Jay Steele hears the skeptics — those who question his model for high school instruction and his ability to turn around a struggling school district, and his boss for not scouring the nation to fill the position he now holds.

Transition Panel’s Plan To Merge Memphis And Shelby Schools: Path To Success Or Tortuous Route?
Commercial Appeal, TN, March 3, 2013

If the unified school board would just “implement the Transition Planning Commission plan” for merging Memphis City and Shelby County schools, a popular refrain goes, everything would be fine.

Directors Oppose Vouchers
Cleveland Daily Banner, TN, March 3, 2013

A proposed school voucher bill by Gov. Bill Haslam has heated up one of education’s hottest topics among parents, legislators and educators of Tennessee.

Ads Touting TN School Vouchers To Top $800K
WSMV, TN, March 1, 2013

A national group advocating for a wide-scale school voucher program in Tennessee is launching a massive media campaign to persuade lawmakers to expand the program proposed by Gov. Bill Haslam.

TEXAS

School Vouchers Appear Dead This Session
Corpus Christi Caller Times, TX, March 4, 2013

There is waning interest by Texas legislators to consider the faux-voucher proposal that has been advocated for months by Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst and Senate Education Committee Chair Dan Patrick, R-Houston. In fact, with no bill yet filed, and with a March 8 deadline looming for introducing legislation, if it is to be considered before the Legislature adjourns on May 27, the voucher proposal is clearly on “life support,” at best.

Area Opinions: Bill Could Help Charter Schools
Lubbock Avalanche Journal, TX, March 3, 2013

Let’s make this clear at the outset: There’s no magic formula for raising the achievement levels of Texas’ 5 million students, but state legislators and school districts can take various steps to give young Texans greater opportunities for a better education. One way is providing enough high-performing charter schools.

WASHINGTON

Senate GOP Scales Back Education Agenda
Seattle Times, WA, March 3, 2013

The Republican wish list is having to confront issues such as cost concerns to arguments that there already have been a lot of school reforms.

WEST VIRGINIA

Debate Over Education Bill Turns To Teacher Hiring
Bluefield Daily Telegraph, WV, March 4, 2013

Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin’s bid to rewrite teacher hiring practices has sparked an early battle as the Legislature wades through his proposed overhaul of West Virginia’s public schools

WISCONSIN

Schools Need Boost, Budget Needs Balance
Wisconsin State Journal, WI, March 3, 2013

More autonomy for public charter schools. These schools are supposed to try new things. So giving them more freedom makes sense, as long as local school boards or some other public entity can stop charters if they’re not working after typically five years.

WYOMING

Teacher Evaluations: A Proposal
Casper Star-Tribune, WY, March 3, 2013

As various bills go forward restructuring Wyoming’s education system a key, if low level, issue is that of a teacher evaluation system. House Bill 72, Statewide Education Accountability – Phase II, directs development of such a system for teachers and administrators.

ONLINE LEARNING

First, Only Virtual School In Mass. Will Be Closed
Boston Globe, MA, March 4, 2013

The state’s first virtual school will shut its digital doors this summer after the Greenfield School Committee voted last week not to submit a proposal to run the Massachusetts Virtual Academy at Greenfield for another year.

Skeptics Of Online Schooling
Daily Free Press, MA, March 3, 2013

Online classes exist for a number of reasons: Nontraditional students (e.g. students who work full-time but need to complete a degree on the side), students who have trouble concentrating and thriving in traditional classroom settings, students who need to save money, students who are far away, etc. They’re a great option to have available to those students who simply cannot thrive in the standard school environment.

State Sen. Judy Schwank Introduces Bill That Would Change Rules On Cyber Charter Schools
Reading Eagle, PA, March 3, 2013

Public school districts in Pennsylvania have been complaining for years about the growing costs of cyber charter schools.

Bill Requiring Online Learning Amended Because Of Opposition
The Herald-Mail, MD, March 3, 2013

Maryland currently doesn’t have a requirement that high school students take an online class as a condition for graduation.

Tennessee Getting Schooled By K12
Knoxville News Sentinel, TN, March 3, 2013

One business that’s been taking on a government job lately is K12, a publicly traded corporation that Tennessee has hired to teach more and more of our children online.

Grapevine-Colleyville District Will Offer A Fully Online School
Star-Telegram, TX, March 3, 2013

Students from across Texas could be enrolling in the Grapevine-Colleyville school district before next school year. Trustees recently approved a plan to provide $196,000 in seed money to create an open-enrollment virtual academy. The academy will serve 400 to 500 nontraditional full-time students and will boost the district’s declining enrollment.

Making Digital Leap Presents Real Challenges For Classrooms
The Oklahoman, OK, March 4, 2013

NOT so long ago, brick and mortar schools were about the only kind of schools that existed. Growing numbers of people choosing to home school have only slightly disrupted the traditional model. Even the increasing popularity of virtual schools is only slightly upending what we think of as “school.”

Online Charter School Offers Enrollment Information
Statesman Journal, OR, March 2, 2013

The Oregon Connections Academy has announced that its spring enrollment season begins Monday with a series of in-person and online information sessions.

First Fridays: Washington Yu Ying Public Charter School

March 1, 2013

First Fridays, a monthly charter school tour event sponsored by CityBridge Foundation, FOCUS and Charter Board Partners, gives people in the DC metro area a chance to see some truly amazing schools at work. Today, our VP of Research, Alison Consoletti, with 25 other choice supporters, checked out Washington Yu Ying Public Charter School, an elementary Chinese language immersion school.

This school, opened in 2008, now serves 439 students in grades PreK-5. While walking through the school halls, the 5th grade student tour guide explained how all subjects – even Chemistry – are taught in both English and Chinese.

Our group got to sit in on a PreK class, where 100% of their school day is taught in Chinese. Students from all walks of life were singing and acting out songs in Chinese, while also learning what the characters meant. It was truly a sight to see.

Since Yu Ying has been open, the school has performed stellar academically, and today is rated Tier 1 Status, according to DCPCSB’s Performance Management Framework.

There were over 700 applications for just 70 spots this last year. And because demand for a challenging immersion program is so high, Yu Ying is working with other immersion charter schools in DC to create DC International, a middle and high-school that would offer International Baccalaureate and continued foreign language instruction.

We can’t wait to see what school First Fridays is going to take us to next!

A Pretty Good Sales Pitch For MA Charter Schools

March 1, 2013

In a follow-up to their initial 2009 report on the Bay State, CREDO has released its latest Charter School Performance Report on Massachusetts, a six year study that analyzes the effectiveness of Massachusetts’s charter schools and in particular, their performance in the Boston area.

The report was largely positive on both math and reading tests, notably when comparing Boston charter schools to their public school counterparts. When analyzing just Beantown charters, the report found that 83 percent had significantly positive learning gains in both reading and math and no city charters were performing lower than the local public schools. That’s a pretty good sales pitch for charter schools in Massachusetts.

For a little more background on CER’s long history with CREDO and our concerns with their methodology, which they use in this report, here’s a link to help you out: a little intro to CREDO.

Daily Headlines for March 1, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

Teachers Outnumbered In Schools By Administrators, Support Staff In Many States, Study Shows
Washington Times, DC, February 28, 2013

Each day at school, students in 21 states will see more librarians, bus drivers, coaches, cafeteria workers and office personnel than teachers, according to a new study that examined school hiring patterns over the past 20 years.

Rand Paul: Why An Education System That Leaves So Many Behind?
San Diego Union-Tribune, CA, February 28, 2013

America’s educational system is leaving behind anyone who starts with disadvantages, and that is wrong. Those born in poverty already face significant challenges. For those striving to climb the ladder of success, we must fix our schools.

FROM THE STATES

ALABAMA

Legislature OKs Tax Credits For School Choice
Gadsden Times, AL, February 28, 2013

Republican legislators on Thursday expanded a routine education bill to include tax credits for parents who move their children from failing public schools to private schools, prompting the state school superintendent to withdraw his support and a teachers’ group to assail it as “totally anti-public education.”

ARIZONA

Charter Schools Could Give Preference To Siblings
Arizona Daily Star, AZ, February 28, 2013

Siblings and grandchildren would gain new admission preferences under a charter schools measure backed by Arizona lawmakers.

CALIFORNIA

Adelanto Parent Trigger School Holds Information, Sign-Up Meeting
Contra Costa Times, CA, February 28, 2013

After months of legal wrangling and political drama, the parents who helped oust the teachers and administrators they say failed their children got to meet the woman soon to be in charge of their school.

LAUSD Joins Other Districts In Asking For No Child Left Behind Waivers, Promising To Use Test Scores In Evaluating Teachers
Los Angeles Daily News, CA, February 28, 2013

Los Angeles Unified and eight other California school districts filed a waiver Thursday to the federal No Child Left Behind law, proposing a new system for measuring student achievement and developing better teachers.

COLORADO

Colorado Appeals Court: Douglas County School Voucher System Legal
Denver Post, CO, March 1, 2013

In a case being watched by school-choice advocates, legal experts and both pro-religion and secularist groups around the country, the Colorado Court of Appeals has ruled that Douglas County School District’s voucher system is legal.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Ending ‘Social Promotion’ In D.C. Schools
Washington Post, DC, February 28, 2013

TEACHERS IN THE D.C. public school system are unable to hold back students in most elementary and middle school grades — even when it is clear that students haven’t mastered the skills of the requisite grades, and even when there is complete agreement from school principals.

FLORIDA

Teachers Question Fairness Of New Evaluation System At Hearing
Orlando Sentinel, FL, February 28, 2013

The official purpose of the meeting sounded dry and bureaucratic: Take public input on drafts of two state rules.

GEORGIA

Opponents Of Deal’s DeKalb Move Intensify Criticism
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, February 28, 2013

Pushback over Gov. Nathan Deal’s decision to suspend two-thirds of the DeKalb County school board was intensifying as state negotiators worked behind-the-scenes to avert a Friday showdown in federal court over the move.

Grady County School Granted Charter School Status
WCTV, GA, February 28, 2013

Cairo High School in Grady County is the first school in Southwest Georgia to be granted Charter School status.

IDAHO

Charter School Funding Bill Pulled Back to House Committee, But Passes Again
Boise Weekly, ID, February 28, 2013

A measure that would restructure funding for Idaho charter schools, which passed through the House Education Committee Feb. 26 with a “do pass” recommendation, was pulled back to the same committee this morning in an unusual move that committee Chairman Reed DeMordaunt, an Eagle Republican, said wouldn’t be happening again anytime soon.

ILLINOIS

Dist. 203 Candidates Support New Ways To Evaluate Teachers
Chicago Tribune, IL, March 1, 2013

Candidates for the Naperville Unit District 203 school board say they support changing the way teachers are evaluated, but also called for educators to have extra support and training.

INDIANA

Charter School Charades
The Journal Gazette Blog, IN, February 28, 2013

That sound you heard Wednesday? That was the sound of the Indiana Charter School Board rubber-stamping a real estate deal to benefit a politically connected Fort Wayne business owner.

Does Indiana’s Voucher Program Need Expansion?
StateImpact, IN, February 1, 2013

While supporters are elated to hear Indiana’s fledgling school voucher initiative has helped fill 9,100 open private school seats statewide this year, they say the program must do more than fill seats: it must create new seats.

KENTUCKY

Charter Schools Bill Advances In Kentucky Senate
The Courier-Journal, KY, March 1, 2013

A charter schools bill is on a steady course to clear the Republican state Senate but seems sure to stall when it hits the Democratic House.

LOUISIANA

School Funding Formula For 2013-14 Unlikely To Satisfy State Education Chief John White’s Critics
Times-Picayune, LA, February 28, 2013

Orleans Parish would get $8,526 of state and local funds for each public school student — just $4 more per pupil from this year — under State Education Superintendent John White’s funding formula for 2013-14, a proposal that strips out policy mandates and pushes forward measures for students with disabilities and private school vouchers. White’s plan continues to fund the private school voucher program through public funds but introduces a contingency plan in case the state Supreme Court rules the current law unconstitutional.

Voucher Changes Under Discussion
The Advocate, LA, February 28, 2013

Despite insisting that a challenge to Louisiana’s expanded voucher law will fail, state Superintendent of Education John White said Thursday he has talked with plaintiffs in the lawsuit about changing the way the program is financed.

MARYLAND

Proposed Law Would Force School Boards To Heed Parents’ Petitions For School Reform
Maryland Reporter, MD, February 28, , 2013

National education reform advocates support a Maryland bill that would mandate reform for failing schools whenever a majority of parents petition for intervention, but the state superintendent and the state teachers union oppose the idea.

MASSACHUSETTS

Neighborhood Over Quality In School Plan?
Boston Globe, MA, March 1, 2013

ON MONDAY night, cameras flashed, hugs were exchanged, and everyone congratulated the External Advisory Committee on School Choice on its selection of a new student assignment plan for the Boston Public Schools. Based in both family address and school MCAS performance, the assignment model answers the call for “quality schools, close to home.”

Lowell Charter School Off Probation
Lowell Sun, MA, March 1, 2013

Lowell Community Charter Public School Head Kathy Egmont likens the school’s transformation to the Mill City itself.

MICHIGAN

Charter School Movement Firing Back At Critics
Oakland Press, MI, March 1, 2013

Michigan’s charter school movement is arming itself with data, fighting back against charges its schools are getting too much tax money, not taking special education students and underachieving.

MISSISSIPPI

House-Senate Talks Warm Up On Charter School Bills
Clarion Ledger, MS, March 1, 2013

Mississippi lawmakers are trying to resolve differences between House and Senate versions of bills expanding charter schools in the state.

NEVADA

Charter Renewed for Andre Agassi College Preparatory Academy
Las Vegas Review-Journal, NV, February 28, 2013

Andre Agassi College Preparatory Academy received a six-year contract extension from the Clark County School District on Thursday.

NEW JERSEY

Charter School Debate Sheds Light on Crisis of Identity Politics
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, March 1, 2013

There was an interesting, and telling, article recently in NJ Spotlight. It looks at a charter school debate in Florence Township, a small suburb in Burlington County. The article sheds light on the tension between the public and private sector, and the crisis of the original identity politics — white identity politics.

State Renews 13 Charter Schools But Flunks Three Others
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, March 1, 2013

Thirteen of 16 charter schools up for renewal this year have been approved by the Christie administration, but three others – including one of the state’s oldest, in Jersey City – had their renewals denied.

Charter Schools In Jersey City, Atlantic City And Hammonton Set To Close
Star-Ledger, NJ, February 28, 2013

The state Department of Education will close charter schools in Jersey City, Atlantic City and Hammonton at the end of the academic year because of low test scores and problems with the schools’ leadership, state education officials said tonight.

NEW MEXICO

PEC Appeals Skandera’s Charter Ruling
Albuquerque Journal, NM, March 1, 2013

The Public Education Commission is taking education secretary-designate Hanna Skandera to court over her decision to approve two charter school applications the commission had denied.

NEW YORK

New Curriculum on Tap
Wall Street Journal, March 1, 2013

New York City next year will transform the way students in kindergarten through eighth grade learn math and English, introducing a new curriculum and recommending new books for the first time in a decade, officials said Thursday.

Are Tough New State Tests Too Much, Too Soon?
Syracuse Post-Standard, NY, March 1, 2013

State tests for elementary and middle school students are two months away, but teachers, administrators and state education officials already agree on one point: Scores are going to drop.

NORTH CAROLINA

Voucher Ploy Could Be Disastrous For Public Schools
News & Observer, NC, February 28, 2013

Public school superintendents have long fought an idea that rears up from time to time in the General Assembly: giving public money to parents for the purpose of paying for private schools for their children. Republican lawmakers, more inclined to push this idea now that they have control on Jones Street, should instead pull the reins.

OHIO

Cleveland Schools Will Fall Under State Oversight By Academic Distress Commission
Cleveland Plain Dealer, OH, February 28, 2013

The state will begin overseeing the Cleveland school district now that its report card rating of Academic Emergency is official, according to the Ohio Department of Education.

Charter Schools Criticize Audit That Claims State Is Owed $860,000
Dayton Daily News, OH, February 28, 2013

The Ohio auditor’s office on Thursday again issued findings for recovery involving Dayton’s Richard Allen Academy charter schools, saying their management company, Institute of Management and Resources Inc., owes taxpayers nearly $860,000.

CSR Is Charter School Getting It Right
Cincinnati Herald, OH, February 28, 2013

CSR has climbed out of an Academic Emergency status inherited from the closed W. E. B. DuBois Academy it replaced during its first year to the status of Continuous Improvement, both designations attached by the Ohio Department of Education. At the same time, CSR received a rare “Above’’ in Value Added, meaning the scholars are progressing at a rate faster than standard, improving by more than one grade level each year.

ACLU Asks Ohio Department of Education to Extend Seclusion and Restraint Policy to Charter Schools
StateImpact, OH, February 28, 2013

The ACLU of Ohio sent a letter to the State Board of Education today asking them to include charter schools in the draft rules that will govern the use of seclusion and restraint in Ohio’s schools.

OKLAHOMA

Okla. Panel Approves Charter School Overhaul Bill
Durant Democrat, OK, February 28, 2013

An Oklahoma state senator pointed to Oklahoma charter schools’ low national rankings and a lack of statewide standards Wednesday to convince the Senate Appropriations Committee that the state should take over the charters’ authorization.

Oklahoma Lawmakers’ Use Of ‘Local Control’ Could Rob Students
The Oklahoman, OK, February 28, 2013

IF lawmakers believe school mandates are unfunded, here’s a solution: Fund them.

PENNSYLVANIA

Philadelphia School Superintendent Defends Teacher Contract Proposal
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, March 1, 2013

William R. Hite Jr. wants you to know: He does not want to drive teachers out of the Philadelphia School District.

Recovery Committee Looking At Three Options For York City Schools
York Dispatch, PA, March 1, 2013

The York City School District’s future may go one of three ways: Going to all charters. Consolidating with neighboring districts. Or allowing the district to come up with internal transformation.

Denied Charter Schools Weigh Their Options
Journal Register, PA, March 1, 2013

When Wendy Ormsby first set out to establish the Souderton Area Charter School Collaborative in 1999, the school board denied her application.

TENNESSEE

All Metro Schools Will Be Great, Given Time
The Tennessean, TN, March 1, 2013

It is becoming a familiar refrain: Metro schools aren’t improving quickly enough; we need better schools now so our students can get a better education right away.

TEXAS

Charter Schools Don’t Let This Divert Attention From Funding
Gilmer Mirror, TX, February 28, 2013

The charter school reforms offered in SB 2 put quantity ahead of quality in the name of offering school choice.

WEST VIRGINIA

Governor, Teachers Unions Primed For Battle Over School Reform
Charleston Daily Mail, WV, March 1, 2013

Battle lines have been drawn over education reform in the state Legislature.
On one side, Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin and his staff said their proposed changes would move West Virginia education in a positive direction.

WISCONSIN

New Appleton Charter School Would Focus On Technical Education
Green Bay Press-Gazette, WI, February 28, 2013

A new charter school that caters to Appleton students interested in technical education classes could open as early as September 2014.

MPS Must Start Up The Laboratory Again
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, WI, February 28, 2013

Wisconsin’s unofficial nickname as “the laboratory of democracy” is largely due to Milwaukee’s experimentation in educational policies. The city pursued a variety of educational reforms until 1990, when it decided to become the first community to adopt a school voucher program, effectively stalling experimentation.

ONLINE LEARNING

Legislation Will Hurt Cyber Schools
Chambersburg Public Opinion, PA, February 28, 2013

The recent article, “Group: School districts overpay for cyber schools,” reflects an unfortunate misunderstanding of education funding, economics and the impact of proposed legislation.

Metro Schools Offer Spring Math Credits
The Tennessean, TN, March 1, 2013

Metro Nashville Public Schools Virtual School is offering Bridge Math Intensive, which starts during spring intersession, to give Metro seniors a chance to earn the needed credit and graduate in May.

Khan Academy Pilot Set For 47 Idaho Schools
Idaho Press Tribune, ID, March 1, 2013

More than 10,000 kindergarten through 12th grade students across Idaho will be part of the nation’s first statewide pilot of the Khan Academy, a release from Northwest Nazarene University said.

Why Truly Independent and Multiple Authorizers Are Important

February 28, 2013

It’s not surprising that Louisiana’s charter school authority expansion fell flat in its first year.

Louisiana’s experience is proof that not all efforts to improve laws are created equal. Strong charter school laws do not require new groups to apply to become authorizers. It is actually a disincentive to do so.

Strong laws permit universities and other publicly accountable non-education entities to become authorizers without asking permission and hold them accountable for the outcomes of their schools. That’s because the purpose of independent and multiple authorizers is to establish new pathways for school creation and oversight separate from existing state and local education agencies.

States that allow for truly independent authorizers, granted by law to operate with unbridled freedom, yield greater charter school growth and quality.

Daily Headlines for February 28, 2013

NEWSWIRE IS BACK! Click here for the latest weekly report on education news and commentary you won’t find anywhere else, spiced with a dash of irreverence, from the nation’s leading voice in school reform.

FROM THE STATES

ALABAMA

Common Core Controversy
Times Daily, AL, February 28, 2013

More than 100 people crowded into the Alabama House chamber for a public hearing Wednesday on legislation that would repeal education standards known as Common Core, previously adopted by the state school board for the public schools.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

DC Public Schools Start Campaign To Hang Onto Students
Washington Examiner, DC, February 27, 2013

DC Public Schools has started an “aggressive” campaign to persuade parents whose children attend one of 15 schools being closed not to abandon the school system for charter or private schools.

Plan Approved For D.C.’s Largest Charter School
Washington Examiner, DC, February 27, 2013

The DC Public Charter School Board has approved what could become the District’s largest charter school.

FLORIDA

Seminole: New Evaluations Imperil Good Teachers’ Jobs
Orlando Sentinel, FL, February 27, 2013

Seminole County schools are among the highest performing in the state. Yet hundreds of Seminole teachers could end up with poor job reviews next year under Florida’s proposed system for calculating teacher evaluations.

Florida Democrats Seek To Cushion Expected Changes To Charter School Law
Tampa Bay Times Blog, FL, February 27, 2013

Majority Republicans in the Florida House and Senate have made no secret of their desire to expand the reach of charter schools in the state, with legislation filed to give charters more access to construction funds and to allow even more growth of the publicly funded, privately run schools.

GEORGIA

Jerguson Recommended For Charter Council
Cherokee Tribune, GA, February 28, 2013

Former state Rep. Sean Jerguson was recommended to fill a recently vacated seat on Cherokee Charter Academy’s Local Governing Council during its meeting Wednesday.

IDAHO

Idaho Legislature Considers Overhaul Of State’s Charter School Law
Boise State Public Radio, ID, February 28, 2013

Idaho lawmakers are considering a re-write of the state’s charter school law. Thursday they’ll hear from the public.

Committee Advances Charter School Funding Bill
Coeur d’Alene Press, ID, February 27, 2013

A House committee has taken a step toward putting Idaho’s collection of charter schools in a better financial position to pay their monthly building and maintenance bills.

ILLINOIS

CPS Cracks Down On Underperforming Charters
Chicago Tribune, IL, February 27, 2013

The Chicago Public Schools board indicated it plans to place more scrutiny on the academic and financial performance of charter schools, approving plans Wednesday to gradually close two charters and warning six others that they’ll have to shape up or face the same fate.

INDIANA

New Charter Approved If Requirements Met
The Journal Gazette, IN, February 28, 2013

The Indiana Charter School Board voted 5-1 Wednesday to approve a Carpe Diem Indiana charter school for Fort Wayne – with some conditions.

Imagine Says Ball State Is Not Communicating
The Journal Gazette, IN, February 28, 2013

Imagine MASTer Academy board President Pat Sheean expressed frustration during a meeting Wednesday about the lack of communication with Ball State University, which is the charter school’s authorizer until June.

Charter Schools Could Be The New Educational Battle Ground
WIBC, IN, February 27, 2013

While the state awaits a decision from the Indiana Supreme Court on the legality of its school voucher program, the new education battle ground may be charter schools.

LOUISIANA

Education Superintendent John White Will Present Alternative Funding Method For School Vouchers
Times-Picayune, LA, February 28, 2013

State Education Superintendent John White said on Wednesday that he will float a voucher-funding proposal Thursday that could sidestep the law’s pending appeal to the state Supreme Court.

Jindal’s Charter Authority Expansion Initiative Falls Flat In First Year
Times-Picayune, LA, February 27, 2013

It was one of the more controversial provisions of Gov. Bobby Jindal’s 2012 education reform package: allowing local nonprofits, public agencies and colleges to grant charters to schools. But when the deadline passed last week for interested entities to submit a letter of intent, not a single group wanted in.

MASSACHUSETTS

State OKs School Charter A Second Time
Haverhill Gazette, MA, February 28, 2013

When students at teachers at Silver Hill Horace Mann Charter School returned from February vacation, a surprise was waiting for them.

NEVADA

The Doral Academy Is An Example Of How To Create An ‘Arts-Integration’ Charter School In A Lot Of Not Particularly Easy Steps
Las Vegas City Life, NV, February 27, 2013

Whoever heard of something rising from the ashes of a phoenix? That’s what’s taking place just off the 215 Beltway on the far west side of town. Doral Academy of Nevada charter school is moving into a former University of Phoenix campus and plans to hold its first classes in August.

NEW JERSEY

Charter-School Reform, On Back Burner, Starts to Heat Up Again
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, February 28, 2013

Talk of revising the state’s charter-school law is picking up again, with one major player now saying that he plans to have a bill ready by spring or early summer.

PENNSYLVANIA

Reading Board Denies Application For Charter Middle School
Reading Eagle, PA, February 28, 2013

An application to create a new charter middle school in Reading was denied Wednesday night by the Reading School Board.

Pittsburgh School Board Rejects 2 Charter Schools; 3rd Tabled
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, February 28, 2013

The Pittsburgh Public Schools board Wednesday night rejected two applications to open charter schools this fall and tabled a third, effectively denying it because of requirements to act within a certain time window.

Lehigh Valley Superintendents Implore Lawmakers For Charter, Special Education Funding Reforms
Lehigh Valley Express-Times, PA, February 27, 2013

A group of Lehigh Valley superintendents today detailed the impact of state budget cuts on their districts and implored Democratic legislators to reform Pennsylvania’s charter school laws.

RHODE ISLAND

Teacher Evaluations Too Lengthy; Won’t Help
Valley Breeze, RI, February 27, 2013

The new teacher evaluation system in Rhode Island requires too much of a teacher’s time to implement and requires teachers to change many of their long-held teaching techniques. Many teachers feel that this new system will burn them out and decrease their effectiveness.

TENNESSEE

TN Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman Says Charters Can Serve Better
The Tennessean, TN, February 28, 2013

Tennessee Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman thinks most school systems are big bureaucracies that waste money that should be spent on students. At least that is what he told an audience of about 60 people Wednesday at Vanderbilt University.

Charter Schools Hurt MNPS
The Tennessean, TN, February 28, 2013

Charter schools are not the answer to the problems of the Metro Nashville Public Schools.

TEXAS

Big School Reforms Should Be The Goal, Jeb Bush Says
Fort Worth Star-Telegram, TX, February 27, 2013

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush urged Texas to swing for the fences when overhauling public education, telling state senators Wednesday that he was able to transform foundering schools in his home state with big — if often unpopular — ideas.

WASHINGTON

Coalition Files Legal Challenge To State Charter-Schools Law
Seattle Times, WA, February 27, 2013

A coalition of educators and community groups on Wednesday filed a legal challenge with the state attorney general, questioning the constitutionality of Washington’s new charter schools law.

Washington Attorney General Plans to Follow Voters’ Will on Charter School Law
KNDO, WA, February 28, 2013

Washington State’s Attorney General says his job is to follow the will of the voters when it comes to the charter school law.
And that’s what he plans to do in response to a legal challenge to that voter-approved charter schools law.

Any Charter School Is One Too Many For State Teachers’ Union
MyNorthwest, WA, February 27, 2013

The Washington Education Association is challenging the law voters approved last fall to create up to 40 charter schools in the state within the next five years.

WEST VIRGINIA

Education Bill May Be On Fast Track In Senate
The Herald-Dispatch, WV, February 28, 2013

Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin’s public education reform bill — introduced only three days ago — is considered to be on the fast track in the West Virginia Senate. But Sen. Erik Wells, D-Kanawha, predicted Wednesday that the Senate Education Committee will be preparing a committee substitute before sending it to the Senate Finance Committee.

WISCONSIN

More than 120 Schools Plan to Participate in Voucher Program in the Next School Year
WUMN, WI, February 27, 2013

The state Department of Public Instruction says 123 private nonsectarian and religious schools have registered to accept students in the coming school year, as part of the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program. Another 13 schools have registered to participate in the school choice program in Racine.

Scott Walker’s Plan Would Give Charter Schools More Autonomy
Wisconsin State Journal, WI, February 27, 2013

Wisconsin school boards would have less control over their own charter schools under Gov. Scott Walker’s state budget proposal.

ONLINE LEARNING

Bill To Incentivize Year-Round School, Blended Learning Clears Committee
Deseret News, UT, February 27, 2013

More schools may consider implementing a year-round schedule or blended learning in classrooms if a bill advanced Wednesday by the Senate Education Committee becomes law.

Senate Approves Online Charter School Moratorium
Associated Press, February 28, 2013

New Mexico would impose a temporary moratorium on new fully online charter schools under a proposal approved by the Senate.

Jindal’s charter authority expansion initiative falls flat in first year

by Danielle Dreilinger
Times-Picayune
February 27, 2013

It was one of the more controversial provisions of Gov. Bobby Jindal’s 2012 education reform package: allowing local nonprofits, public agencies and colleges to grant charters to schools. But when the deadline passed last week for interested entities to submit a letter of intent, not a single group wanted in.

That was a surprise to Scott Richard, executive director of the Louisiana School Boards Association. “I would’ve expected at least one or two applications,” he said. The association is a plaintiff in a school vouchers lawsuit against the department.

Before the state law was passed last year, the power to authorize charters had been restricted to local school districts and the state Board of Elementary and Secondary Education.

The spokesman for the state Department of Education downplayed the lack of applicants. “It was the first year and we did have lots of interest,” said Barry Landry. “Groups are still considering [it].”

The provision is part of a number of changes that aim to expand the number of charters in Louisiana. Even with the state’s high visibility for recent education reforms, fewer than 10 percent of public schools are charters, according to Department of Education data released in January.

Like local and state school boards, a local charter authority would receive, evaluate and grant applications for independent groups to open schools, and then evaluate the performance of those schools. Students could come from anywhere in the state.

Charter advocates and opponents had a number of explanations for why no one took advantage of the opportunity, including limited outreach, tough rules and general satisfaction with the current chartering system.

For one, the eligibility standards are stringent. Applicants must have an educational mission, at least $500,000 in net assets, and have been incorporated for at least 3 years — meaning no one can set up a group just to become a charter authorizer.

No administrator can have been convicted of a felony. Authorizers also must have open meetings and make records available to the public.

The evaluation rules are stringent as well. After a local charter authority’s first school has been open for 3 years, the state reviews the performance of all the group’s schools. If they have an average academic performance grade of D or F, the organization loses its authorizing power and the schools are turned over to the state. An average of C means the group holds on to its schools but cannot authorize any new ones until scores improve.

That’s a high bar, said John Ayers, executive director of Tulane University’s Cowen Institute. “Charter schools often seek to educate hard-to-serve youngsters, who are often behind state averages on scholastic aptitude metrics. Getting all your schools to C in 3 years is a big challenge.”

The state also could intervene and rescind a charter at any time if it found a school neglected, abused or mistreated students.

Ayers and various Louisiana charter advocates approve of those rules. “You can’t just give a free hand to charter authorizers,” said Neerav Kingsland, CEO of New Schools for New Orleans. “I think Louisiana’s law was cognizant of that.”

State Rep. Steve Carter, R-Baton Rouge, who worked on the bill, said local community leaders had expressed interest in starting schools to meet needs in a region. “Until now, they have had to work through the current system to do so,” he said.

But when the law was written last year there was no groundswell of nonprofits clamoring to become chartering authorities, said Caroline Roemer Shirley, executive director of the Louisiana Association of Public Charter Schools: “It was not based on demand.”

Rather, it was a top-down decision aligned with national policy trends. Influential organizations including the Center for Education Reform, StudentsFirst and the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools emphasize the importance of having multiple pathways to create charters. Currently, 19 states plus the District of Columbia allow for “independent and multiple authorizers,” said Kara Kerwin of the Center for Education Reform.

The national experience with local charter authorities has been mixed and may have dissuaded some potential applicants. In New York, the state university network charters schools and has been generally well regarded. But overall it hasn’t gone well, said Ayers. In Indiana, Ball State University is reviewing nearly half of the 42 schools it has chartered and already pulled seven charters, according to reports.

“The extremely problematic Ohio charter movement is the poster child for why this is generally not a good idea, and my understanding is that people pointed that problem out to Gov. Jindal’s people as they pushed for the approach last winter,” Ayers said.

Schools also might not want to apply to local charter authorities for their charters. “It’s such a big unknown,” said Jonathan Bertsch, director of advocacy for KIPP New Orleans. Under the Recovery School District, KIPP has access to school buildings and clear evaluation standards. “Right now we’re in a pretty stable situation and that’s worked for us,” he said, though “it’s definitely an interesting idea.”

The new provision also hasn’t had much visibility. BESE passed the policy in October 2012 with little fanfare. Landry said the Department of Education had preliminary conversations with some foundations and nonprofits but no formal outreach or training.

It hasn’t been a focus for the Louisiana Association of Public Charter Schools either. “It’s a great opportunity,” said Roemer Shirley. “There needs to be some effort behind it. There’s a lot of other moving parts right now.”

In most parts of the state, she said, she still needs to explain that charter schools are public.